"Starting next week, we plan to stop active development on Google Notebook. This means we'll no longer be adding features or offer Notebook for new users. But don't fret, we'll continue to maintain service for those of you who've already signed up. As part of this plan, however, we will no longer support the Notebook Extension, but as always users who have already signed up will continue to have access to their data via the web interface at http://www.google.com/notebook."
I'm disappointed, and it seems I'm not the only one. 538 comments on the blog itself share my reaction, and many bloggers are also quite undone. I doubt such inter-web agitation will save Notebook from the cutting block, but at least we can start the grieving process. :)
What was great about Notebook was, first, that students didn't need another password or user name to access it and Google Docs.
Apart from that was its general ease of use. The browser extensions made it easy to highlight what you wanted from a website and just right-click it into a notebook. Once there, clips could be organized easily with drag-and-drop interface. You could organize clips in sections within a notebook, add comments and tags, and the sharing options were great: web page for links, RSS for a reader, and inviting viewers who didn't have a Google Account was quick and easy.
So, if they won't be offering this service to new users, I'll have to find something else for future students. Ergo, I'm actually using Google Notebook to find a replacement for Google Notebook. It's a little like having an employee train his/her replacement. This is what I've been up to in my spare time since Thursday evening.
So here are the candidates I've come across for a replacement. If you have more, please post in a comment and I'll give them a whirl:
Clipmarks
Diigo-testing now (1/16/09)
Evernote
Ma.gnolia-testing now (1/17/09)
Notefish-testing now (1/17/09)
Springnote
Ubernote
Zoho Notebook-testing now (1/16/09)
I've already discounted a couple of suggestions I've come across because they are primarily bookmarking sites, not actual notebooks in the sense of Google Notebook. These would include de.li.cious, digg, technorati, StumbleUpon, and reddit. Ma.gnolia has some features more like Notebook, so I'm going to try that out. Diigo is trying to add more Notebook like options in their primarily social bookmarking site. I've also discounted Furl because you have to have Furl to share Furl as easily as one could share in Notebook--and it's mostly about save whole pages rather than parts of pages. This may also be what will knock Diigo out of the running, even though you can highlight what you would have clipped in Notebook.
I'll try to share my findings as I find them. :)
Here are some articles that might help you if you're also looking for a replacement:
Seven Worthy Notebook Replacements (CNet News)
Free Tech for Teachers: Choosing a Google Notebook Replacement
Side note: I have seen many comments made by company reps of several of the aforementioned services posted in response to several blogs and articles. If you happen by my little offering to the blogosphere, don't come with that business busy language. I don't want anything robust solutionish except for coffee nor do other euphemistic noun phrases mean much in my book. What I do want is a way to clip easily what I want to clip in a web-based application that has a low learning curve and at least an equivalent of drag-and-drop organization. Oh yeah, free is good. Ask yourself if a 7th grader with hormonal imbalances and a history of little or no computer access could learn your service and use it in 20 minutes or less. If you think your service can do THAT, then I'll take you seriously. :)

No comments:
Post a Comment