Thursday, January 22, 2009

Notefish Review

On January 17, I started looking for Google Notebook replacements. In a comment I found to one of the online articles I consulted was the suggestion of Notefish.

After registering for an account (easy), and downloading the FireFox extension (also easy), I started clipping.

The Notefish browser extension functions much like the Google Notebook browser extension: highlight the text/pictures you want to clip, right click, and Copy to Notefish. I set up multiple notebooks within Notefish. As a result, one thing was different about the clipping process in Notefish. Rather than automatically saving the clipping into the last opened notebook, as in Google Notebook, you have to choose which notebook in Notefish you would like the clipping to be saved. This was cool.

I then went to play with my clippings inside the notebooks. Dragging and dropping to organize clippings is more versatile WITHIN the Notefish notebook. Instead of a list, which is dictated in Google Notebook, I could move clippings all around the notebook: side-by-side, staggered side-by-side, in a list. I could also create sections within a notebook. Also interesting was the ability to resize individual clippings on the page.

You can also color-code clippings quite easily with the small toolbar that floats near the bottom-left of the notebook page. Tags are added by clicking on "Add Tags Now"; however, you can only add tags to an entire notebook rather than to each clipping within a notebook.

The trouble came when I tried to take a clip from one notebook and place it in another. Since Notefish doesn't have a list of your notebooks in a sidebar, like in Google Notebook, I couldn't drag and drop anything among notebooks. Thus, that little difference in the browser interface where you pick the notebook to save to is very, VERY important. There is a way to move clippings from one notebook to another, but it involves the following (not drag-and-drop): "Simply click on top of any of your notes, and a field on the bottom right corner of the screen will appear that reads 'Drop here to move to another project'. Simply drag and drop your notes into this area, and select the project to copy to."

My next problem came when I wanted to share my notebook. Rather than having the share options spelled out for you as in the Google Notebook, you have a box that asks if you would like to share the page, when you want it to expire, and a password protection. No info in the interface on how to get to this shared page to create a link to it in email or on a blog. Rather:
"Open your page, and click the 'Share' link at the top of the page page. You'll be able to make the page shared, create a password and set an expiration date. Once you've set your shared preferences, you can copy and paste the URL of this page into an email and send to others. Make sure you share the password with them, if you've set one." I had to go to the help page to find this information, which is fine for me. This may not be such a good thing for efficiency when teaching 25 7th graders how to use this service within a 65 minutes. With Google Notebook, the sharing options were very clear when you chose to share a page, so if they couldn't remember the directions, there was support within the page to jog their memories.

Altogether, I found Notefish a plain and simple notebook service. Not too far off from Google Notebook, with some better features. However, it lacks the smooth look and feel of Google Notebook, and the extra steps that limit true drag-and-drop among notebooks and the number of times you or students would need to access the help section for steps in a process (instead of gather information) concern me as far as on-page support that would lower the learning curve.

For now, I'm keeping Notefish as an option, but I still have more test-clipping to do with other services.

No comments: