I spent about three hours reading about the differences, disadvantages, and advantages of Furl, del.icio.us, ma.gnolia, and about 19 other places to socially bookmark. Some people use multiple sites at a time to fill the gaps among the separate sites' capabilities.
So far, the big differences seem to be 1. whether or not the service makes a "copy" of the website you add to your bookmarks, 2. whether or not the service allows you to keep bookmarks private, 3. whether or not the service offers persevering (I may have the tech term wrong) highlighting and stickies within the copy of the bookmark (if a copy is made in the first place), 4. the ease of tagging , especially from a browser and 5. how many other people are actually using the service.
I can see the potential for research assistance in finding information but not necessarily keeping it for future use. When a website disappears, the bookmark is useless unless you use a tool that makes a copy of the site as part of the bookmarking and tagging process. The malleability of the web could actually work against you when you actually try to use the information simply because the website or page no longer exists. I think over time that these 19 will slowly dwindle as they copy more and more of each other's features; however, that time may be a long way away. It's been 5 years, and del.icio.us still doesn't make a copy of your bookmarked pages, and furl still makes you assign categories. Since Google plans to get in on this market, they may be smart enough to follow the advice in this article: Furl and Del.icio.us: Almost Perfect Together
In any case, I can see how the bookmark sites would help set parameters for student research before they enter the web--like training wheels. It could also help the teacher guide students to more authoritative sources.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
1 comment:
Thanks for sharing, Furl and Del.icio.us: Almost Perfect Together. It was very helpful!
Post a Comment