Tuesday, June 24, 2008

Thing #22: Nings

Nings contain so many of the other Web 2.0 features we've studied that it seems a little like one-stop shopping. I can see the similarity to MySpace, but Ning allows a lot more freedom to the social network rather than the social network having to conform to a set of rules and formats determined by the service. And like many social sites and blogs, it seems to be either feast or famine. I saw so many nings with only 1 user, and others with hundreds of users and no activity--famine. The examples in Thing #22 (Teacher Librarian Ning, Texas School Librarians Ning, Ning for Teachers) were quite active with lots of information and exchange of ideas--feast!

I like flying_pig's idea of creating focus groups on topics of student interest that they can research and share. She suggests skateboarding as an example, but I could also see groups forming around genres (both reading and writing them), authors, and issues. However, my big concern is when they'll do this. Student computers in secondary classrooms in my district are few and far between. The only alternative we have presently are computer labs (and not the mobile ones). If I was reasonably confident that at least 3/4 of students had computers at home, I think ninging as a version of homework would be received more enthusiastically than simply assigning reading or finishing up writing. But the reality is that 3/4s of our student population does not have consistent Internet or computer access. I hate to take something that is meant to be organic and force it into a 5-minutes-when-I-get-lab-time activity.

As for teachers, I can see how nings could bring teachers from different campuses together for different purposes without having to physically meet, like a SBISD Middle School ELA teacher ning or a Writing Institute Participant Ning. Would anyone from SBISD like or like me start one? Ideas are WELCOME!!!

A few notes on other topics:
In my #20 post, I recommended Comiqs as a comic strip creating tool. If you tried it and liked it, you'll be very impressed with ToonDoo. It was recommended to me by life's a comic strip. If you take a look at his blog you'll see some ToonDoo comics he's made, or just check out the ones at ToonDoo.

I'm skipping #21: Find, Create, and Use Podcasts and Audiobooks for now, but will come back to it next week. Hopefully, I'll finish it and #23 by the 4th of July!

Is anyone else wondering why this was only 18 hours of PD credit when I know I spent more than that on just Things 1-10?

6 comments:

flying_pig said...

Aw, shucks! 'Twern't nuthin!

I'm definitely on board for the teacher ning. I've created a VERY BASIC ning, which I'll post as soon as it's usable (it's VERY rough!!). Let's talk sometime!

Meera said...

Thanks for the mention! Glad to know that you liked toondoo too!

bookeatersclub said...

If someone with your expertise spent 18 hours already, can you imagine how long it took the rest of us to complete the project?

It was all worth it.

I learned so much on my own and also from reading your posts in this session of 23 "Things.". You have quite a bit of knowledge and creative ideas that should be shared with your campus and the district as well. It will be interesting to see where this journey takes you after the 23 "Things" are complete.

Judy B-song said...

I agree with you 100% about spending more than 18 hours doing the 23 things. I wish we could have clocked in and out somehow or other just to have an idea exactly how much time we spent on this project. I did like being able to do this at home!

Grendel said...

I have read quite a few posts lately about the 18 hours of credit. It sounded like a lot at first, but that was before I knew how much time needed to be devoted to this project. I share your pain!
What it ultimately boils down to, I think, is that you are the kind of teacher who recognizes the need for and accepts responsibility for learning new methods and tools for delivering improved instruction to your students. I think you would be actively engaged in learning something further about education even if you were not involved in this particular project.You just think it deserves more than 18 hours, and blogs like yours probably do.Mine didn't, but I didn't know that at the time. I thought it was great. Maybe there is a restriction on the number of hours that can be awarded. I don't know. When you read some posts, you feel the hostility and bitterness coming right through the computer screen, and you wonder why they are even doing this. When you read blogs that are just barely meeting the requirements--no examples, no introspection, just a statement of, " I read it. I did it," you might feel offended that they are getting the same number of hours as you are. But, maybe they are coming from such a self-limited background that what they are doing is a great stride for them!Anyway, I do admire your dedication and your work, and my hat is off to you! :)

Hebrews 13:2 said...

Bruce...
Congratulations on your progress...You are where I want to be...The "23 Things" are one big learning curve...I hope that I make it to the finish line by August 5th...By the way, thanks for sharing the idea of the counter and the map...I've added both of them to my blog...Your blog looks great. :)