When I looked at the list of articles about the future of libraries , I immediately thought of a Engines of Ingenuity episode (2369) I heard on Houston Public Radio about a month or so ago. Dr. John H. Lienhard of the University of Houston reflected on an 1871 Schribner's Monthly article by J. Winser about the Boston Public Library. A debate was occurring within the newly-birthed walls of America's first public libraries: do we only collect books of a certain historical and aesthetic status or do we include the clamor of 2nd, 3rd, and 4th rate fiction. Lienhard puts it this way: "But the public, so often wrong in the short term, is always wiser than the experts in the long run. And the writer catches on grudgingly. He says that the public taste in fiction is low. But if we try to decide for the public, they will simply not use our library. He painfully concedes that starting out with cheap novels will put people on the road to better books."
With this in mind, let me address the assignment for this post: Library 2.0 - It's many things to many people. What does it mean to you? What does it mean for school libraries?
Library 2.0 means a struggle with some very fundamental issues. Underlying the arguments presented in Lienhard's and Winser's articles is the necessity of public entities to choose wisely how it spends its resources. In 1871, it was a decision to purchase time-honored classics or contemporary fiction. In the 21st century, the decision will be between purchasing physical media or investing in digital media. As is evident in the specialization of libraries at present, the answer is probably digital media. But the real question is to what degree?
There is a need for us to confirm, to prove. King Arthur's search for the Holy Grail, the writing down of the Constitution, the birth certificate are all manifestations of a need to touch to believe, to prove. For all of the digital age's wizardry, seeing is not believing. While I can see it, I can't touch it. In this sense, digital media isn't real. Rather, it is an accumulation of electrons in a storage device (if I understand modern technology), so easily changed or erased, not even ashes left to confirm its existence. Physical media, however, carries within itself the tangible reality. If necessary, I can show you the static word on the page as originally written. You know that to forge it, alter it, or destroy takes action beyond pushing a button. Without these touchstones of thought we are without proof. Because of this basic need, there will be a necessity for at least some libraries to continue investing heavily in physical media to provide the proof we all seek from time to time in the printed word, the cuneiform tablet, the markings on the cave walls. Or perhaps, libraries will agree that one will focus on collecting physical media of one sort and share it digitally with other libraries that specialize in other types of physical media. For other libraries, digital media will mean hubs and ease of access of not only the digital creations of now, but the media of the past.
What does this mean for the school library? Notice that this type of library is qualified with the word school. If it is to live up to its name, the a school library must teach and learn. I don't mean to offend, but my experience with public school libraries shows me not much of either is taking place consistently. Rather, it seems like these libraries and librarians are more concerned with rules and territory rather than teaching and learning. A long time ago, an education consultant talked about how the ongoing and increasing use of worksheets in the classroom would turn teachers into technicians rather than professionals. That worksheets were about control, not about teaching or learning. Now look at the recent occurrences with the SBOE, the proliferation of alternative certification programs, the plethora of prepackaged programs. If these aren't the trappings of a view of teachers not as professionals or decision makers, but as technicians who deliver without thought a prescribed program of services, I don't know what does. A similar crossroads is occurring with public school librarians. If the true purpose of a school library is not served through the actions of its librarian, then what is the point of the librarian? If rules and territory are the focus, then a peace officer, not a library scientist, is the correct job description and employee. And more importantly, when a district must choose how to spend its resources wisely, will the librarian be expendable? Will patrons find ways to librarian-proof their library experience?
What makes this exceptionally pertinent to school librarians is the ability of Library 2.0 to usurp the librarian if the library or the librarian does not offer something that technology cannot. However, with Library 2.0 as a guide, the image of the school librarian as enforcer rather than facilitator has never been so easy to change as it is now. Since much of the technology and tools that exist within the parameters of Library 2.0 remain unknown to the average classroom teacher and building administrator, and the pace at which information and tools to access it change, the librarian has a unique opportunity to renew his/her role as a library scientist--the collectors, organizers, preservers and disseminators of information resources, and the political economy of information-- a pathfinder in ways to teach and to learn for a campus of professionals and students.
Sorry if this post rambled on a bit, but the assignment did get me to thinking a lot about these questions. I've never taken a course in library science, and my experience is limited to the few articles I've read in the past few days and my trips to school, public, and university libraries. Let me know if my thinking is completely off. :)
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
2 comments:
You have given me much to think about. You are not the only one to mention librarians, rules, and territory in the same breath. Because I have heard this a lot more than is comfortable for me, we librarians must have a lot of fences to mend. I have never considered the library to be "my" library, and I have never felt particularly powerful as the ruler of the book-people, comfortably enthroned behind the circulation desk, but maybe patrons see me that way.I will be very aware of that as I interact with people this fall.We are told in no uncertain terms by our fearless leader that libraries must be inviting, comfortable, non-threatening, and relevant. If that is not happening in a particular school in this district, keep looking. I would be willing to bet that you will notice changes. Not that I speak from personal experience, of course! :)
First, I want to be clear that what I wrote about librarians is not about ALL librarians. I visited my small town public library about once a week even through high school, I remember the trips to the library in school, I've attended three universities and taught at three different middle schools. I can safely say that I've had multiple encounters with about 15-20 librarians. It wasn't until I taught middle school that I encountered the territorial mentality, or heard about it through the conversations of other teachers.
I think much of the territorial behavior I've seen comes from the librarian's own attitudes about his/her students. If there is a basic distrust of students, a belief they will not do what they're supposed to do unless the librarian is strict or harsh, then this distrust is usually manifested in the way the librarian treats the students when they come in for help or to just look (same is true for several teachers with whom I've worked as well). Problem is, if we've been good about making sure we teach the kind of behaviors we want and the purposes and ways to best use the library, a lot of these problems go away.
I don't begrudge (too much anyway)some librarians' preoccupation with rules and territory because I know that when you only have a certain amount of money to purchase things for the library, every dollar is precious--especially when the money doesn't seem to go as far as it used to. If I had spent a big chunk of my personal income on a library (which I've actually done now that I think of it), I would probably be miffed when that library is misused or abused in some way. I can understand why some librarians get defensive about their libraries--to prevent the misuse and abuse, but there has to be a balance between defense and access. Otherwise, I think these librarians risk losing the very customers from whom they are trying to defend their libraries. This strategy is ultimately self-defeating. If I become so defensive of my holdings and resources that students find me offensive, then I probably won't have a library to defend in the long run.
"We are told in no uncertain terms by our fearless leader that libraries must be inviting, comfortable, non-threatening, and relevant." JUST my opinion :), but one way to do make progress toward these goals is to get data from users--teachers and students--and as many of them as possible. I would be glad to sit with my librarian and talk about what we could do to improve things, and I think there are many teachers who want to see a successful library and would be glad to do the same. Maybe this is one way fences could be mended in a productive way?
Post a Comment